From Confusion to Clarity
By Levi Hayes
As children, we all crave acceptance and belonging. For gay men, this journey often includes painful experiences of shame and exclusion. My childhood, shaped by confusion, resilience, and a search for identity, reflects this struggle.
Born in 1976 in the heart of the Bible Belt, I grew up on a small Midwest farm surrounded by woods and open spaces—an idyllic setting for an energetic little boy. Yet, even as a child, I carried burdens no one should bear. Fragmented memories of being groomed sexually by an adult family member haunt me, though my mind has clouded much of the trauma. What I do remember clearly is his warning that if I ever told, the devil would come for me. That fear silenced me for years.
By third grade, I began to sense I was different, though I did not understand why. On the playground, I was often left out, picked last in gym class, and taunted by peers—especially the other boys. I did not yet know what “gay” or “queer” meant, but I knew I no longer fit in. The teasing turned to fights, and my parents eventually noticed something was wrong.
Rising Tensions
I believe my parents suspected my differences early on but dismissed them as a phase. By my teenage years, however, their denial gave way to shame as the reality of my homosexuality became undeniable. My father became emotionally distant, while my mother’s attempts at acceptance were clouded by her own confusion and fear.
As the subject of my sexuality seemed to take center stage, our home became filled with constant tension and arguments. Often these arguments escalated from discipline to full on physical abuse. I felt lost during my teenage years, without a sense of identity or belonging—neither at home nor at school.
Looking back, my heart breaks for my younger self, realizing that even before I understood myself, shame was being programmed into me. I was being taught that something about me was unlovable, and this happened during a critical time in my life when the foundation for my self-perception was being laid. This was just the first of many societal and familial tensions I began to internalize.
All gay men cope with feelings of inadequacy in diverse ways. During this time, many chose to conceal their true selves behind a mask of hyper-masculinity, blending into straight society by adopting traditional heterosexual behaviors. While this offers them a form of validation, it is ultimately superficial. Others, like me, who were not as good at acting, who did not meet society’s expectations of masculinity and had no choice but to try to hide. Our mannerisms, voices, or other traits made our homosexuality unmistakable, leaving us vulnerable to judgment and ridicule—even from more masculine, closeted, “straight-acting” gay men. After all, our visible existence only served to intensify their own internal sense of shame. Truth is much of these dynamic between homosexual men and how they treat each other is still true today.
For me, this meant growing up without validation from family or peers. I felt like an outsider everywhere I turned—emasculated and unable to trust men or male figures. Thankfully, I was surrounded by strong, nurturing female friends who saw my pain and befriended me. In a sense, I hid behind women, though I am certainly not the first gay man to do so. These women became my lifeline, offering love, safety, friendship, and validation. But while this bond was beautiful and meaningful, it was not the male bonding I deserved as a young man.
Loneliness
Men who miss meaningful male bonding experiences also miss out on crucial skills that help foster belonging, identity, and social connection. These experiences could have helped counteract the isolation and shame I felt during my formative years.
Looking back, I can see how the almost daily torment from my peers, the rejection from my family, and societal disdain for my homosexuality made the validation I received from the women in my life all the more appealing. Their support felt like safety, especially when it affirmed the traits others mocked—even if those traits were more feminine in nature.
Even into adulthood, like most gay men, I spent much of my life searching for the validation I never received as a child. I constantly vacillated between being overwhelmed by my shame and trying to hide it or trying to compensate for it. For me, a man stunted in childhood, my coping mechanisms with these struggles eventually took the form of drugs, alcohol, and extreme promiscuity. It all stemmed from that deep sense of shame ingrained in me from childhood. Truth is much of these dynamic between homosexual men and how they treat each other is still true today.
In 2016, at 39, I experienced an extremely traumatic event that pushed me to my mental boundaries and brought my unresolved childhood issues roaring back, along with it I became depressed and socially isolated for several months. This was enough to trigger my self-loathing, internal homophobic inner critic that had been developed and refined since early childhood. Memories of my childhood bullying resurfaced, accompanied by the same dissociative feelings I once associated with being called “dirty faggot,” “queer” and any number of slurs as a boy. As well, I vividly recalled my mother telling me, “If you choose to be gay, you will die alone and with AIDS.” With that, I began to see my homosexuality as the source of all the suffering and pain I had endured in my life.
Amid my resurfacing trauma and self-imposed isolation, I reflected on the validation I’d received from women throughout my life and recalled my early experiments with cross-dressing as a boy, along with the sense of affirmation I thought I found in being a drag entertainer earlier in life—it felt like my place in the LGBT+ community. This reaction occurred during a time when the media was heavily focused on trans identities and the importance of affirming them—stories like Caitlyn Jenner and the broader gender ideology narrative. Looking back, I now understand how gender ideology can act as a social contagion. It set the stage for me to convince myself that I was really a woman trapped in a man’s body, and that was reality of my problem all along. I came to believe that transitioning would “fix” everything—the shame, the longing for acceptance, and my deep desire for belonging. It was at that point I became convinced and began self-identifying as transgender.
I thought transitioning would help me fit into society, make being with a man “normal,” and even win my parents’ approval by presenting me as “straight.” I sought out an affirming therapist and, with no medical gatekeeping, was diagnosed with gender dysphoria after just two one-hour therapy sessions. This diagnosis fast-tracked me toward irreversible changes without anyone encouraging me to explore deeper issues: my family dynamics, internalized shame, or the lingering effects of my trauma.
Not one “professional” ever told me, No.
The truth is, I did not recognize that I was living in a state of trauma, grappling with internalized homophobia and the emotional scars of a lifetime of horror. I also did not realize that the disconnected feeling I had from my body—something I had experienced off and on since childhood during moments of fear, intimidation, or trauma—was most likely dissociation. What I now understand is that dissociation, while initially a protective mechanism, may have failed me. It mimicked the sensations associated with gender dysphoria, leading me down a path that was not right for me.
I lived eight years as a transgender woman, and sure, my feelings of inadequacy and rejection were gone temporarily. Surgeries and attention give a certain amount of euphoria that you just end up seeking more of, but all I did was change my appearance without addressing the fractured parts of me I had tried so desperately to escape. And those fractures eventually caught up with me in many ways.
Waking Up
Since awakening to the reality of what happened to me, I have learned that the detransition journey is much slower than a typical affirming transition. When your mind awakens to this reality and makes the decision to detransition, it is ahead of the body and that can feel like madness. Nonetheless, I continue my path to authenticity, learning to rewrite my story—one where acceptance comes from within, free from the shame and guilt that once held me captive. My hope now is for young men—gay or otherwise—to grow into themselves without the pressure to change, hide, or conform. I want them to know they are enough, just as they are. Sadly, my story isn’t unique. The landscape of gay culture has shifted in ways that often leave me wondering: Will there still be space for young gay boys to simply grow up as themselves, without the pressure to conform to a specific narrative? Or will they, too, feel forced to change parts of themselves to fit into a world that does not allow them the room to just be?
Genspect publishes a variety of authors with different perspectives. Any opinions expressed in this article are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect Genspect’s official position. For more on Genspect, visit our FAQs.